
In the midst of the alarming social, political, and economic situation we are entering at an unexpected pace, a torrent of irrational and escapist reactions has emerged among us. I also find them petty.
I don't intend to analyze them all here, as that would be impossible, and I also lack the means to do so. But, from my position as an art historian and a minor member of the cultural field, I have been observing the emergence and growing strength of a discourse of toxic positivity, specifically in the art world.
A depoliticized discourse, devoid of any serious reflection, that posits art as a refuge from what is happening and what will happen, assuming that an autonomous field could actually exist in the minefield through which we move.
Toxic positivity has come to me in the form of inspirational messages (“let us find refuge in beauty”), economic aberrations (“we’re so smart, we’ll never be short of work”) and senile self-care (“you have to protect yourself from what is coming or you will get sick”).
While I doubt these three attitudes are unique to the circles I move in, they do reveal something structural: the art world continues to see itself as an ivory tower (or a glass castle, as a colleague suggested to me yesterday). And the promise of beauty remains undiminished.
I want to highlight something that remains true even though some of us (those of us who are working class) know it all too well. The art world is classless. Or rather, the art world sees itself as classless, as if it existed outside of class hierarchies. And while this issue is always present and puts those of us who need to work to live in a highly vulnerable position, it becomes even more burdensome during times of economic crisis. Perhaps that's why economic absurdities make their grand entrance, claiming that everything will be fine because "I'm smart." As if intelligence (rather than connections or, more vaguely, symbolic capital) guaranteed anything.
What they really mean is that Mom and Dad pay for it. Their own house, a little car, various installments. The art world remains a world of inherited privilege, despite the radical inclusion policies in management, production, and research that we've witnessed in recent decades.
Wretches.